Università Roma Tre

The aim of the teaching is to take the economic evaluation as a logical and methodological aid to design choices and as an active component in the construction of the restoration project. The aim is to provide the fundamental elements for the evaluation, seen as a contribution to the construction of the preferable solution with respect to the context and to prefigured feasibility requirements.

The lessons will deal with the following issues:

1. Estimation procedures and restoration costs analysis.
After some considerations on nature, classification and variability of restoration costs, the synthetic, analytical and intermediate estimation procedures are illustrated, highlighting some critical and problematic aspects existing in the different phases and design scales. In the context of the analytical cost estimate, a specific study concerns the formation of new prices even in cases of traditional building techniques.

2. Evaluation methods and techniques for projects, plans and programs.
The following topics are addressed:
* investment analysis, aimed at controlling the cost-revenue ratio that the project is able to develop over time;
* economic evaluation, aimed at examining utility and disutility that the project is able to provide to the community as a whole;
* multidimensional social evaluations, to extend the economic-financial evaluation of the project to other dimensions (historical, aesthetic-cultural, environmental, technical, social, procedural, etc.) in order to support design choices with a wider spectrum of information broad and above all, more suited to the complexity of current phenomena.

The teaching is structured through theoretical lessons and exercises, concerning the valuation of the costs of the restoration.

Miccoli S., “La valutazione nel progetto di restauro”, in G. Carbonara (diretto da), “Trattato di restauro architettonico”, UTET, Torino, 1996.
Lecture notes provided by the teacher

The didactic activity of the Restoration Laboratory Course will provide to every student the operative fundamentals (cognitive, critical and technical) addressed to the knowledge of the method of an architectonic Restoration project: for every case of study, such method will be also experienced by the student, by personally drawing, under the guidance of tutors, a restoration project concerning ancient, medieval or modern prominent building or urban sites. For this purpose, every project will be instructed by deepening both requested historical and analytical aspects to the extent of the detailed working drawing. Furthermore, the didactic activity will be structured in modules aimed at contributing to the projects by both producing specific didactic materials and organizing practical guided activities as far as survey drawings and appropriate installation approaches to every case of study will be concerned.
The final examination, which will consist in individual, oral test, will focus on the discussion about the planning exercises and the general subjects highlighted by the course.

- A. Pugliano, Criteri per il restauro strutturale e antisismico nell’edilizia storica, in: P. Marconi, Manuale del Recupero del centro storico di Palermo, Flaccovio, Palermo 1997
- A. Pugliano, L’organismo architettonico premoderno. Consuetudini costruttive e compagine
materiale dell’edilizia storica di ambiente romano, in: P. Marconi, Manuale del Recupero del
Comune di Roma, II edizione ampliata, Dei, Roma 1997
- A. Pugliano, Anatomia dell'organismo architettonico, in: Luca Zevi (a cura), Manuale del Restauro Architettonico, Mancosu, Roma 2001.
- A. Pugliano (a cura), Restauro architettonico e Restauro archeologico, volume monografico di "Ricerche di Storia dell'Arte" nn. 74-75, Carocci, Roma 2001 (ma 2002)
- A. Pugliano, Con il fine di Conservare, in: AA.VV. “L’esame di Stato”, Prospettive edizioni, Roma, 2007.
- P. Marconi, A. Pugliano (a cura) Progettare il Restauro Architettonico numero monografico di: “Ricerche di Storia dell’Arte” n. 93, Carocci, Roma, 2007.
- A. Pugliano, Il Riconoscimento, la Documentazione, il Catalogo dei Beni Architettonici. Elementi di un costituendo Thesaurus utile alla Conoscenza, alla Tutela, alla Conservazione dell’Architettura, 2 voll. Prospettive edizioni, Roma 2009.
- A. Pugliano, "Il terremoto e la città", in: "Ricerche di Storia dell'Arte", n. 99, Carocci, Roma 2010.
- A. Pugliano, Strumenti e metodi per la Conservazione e la Valorizzazione di architetture e siti urbani d'interesse archeologico. Il caso di Ostia Antica, in: R.M. Strollo (a cura) Disegno e Restauro, Aracne, Roma 2010.
- P. Marconi, A. Pugliano (a cura), Architettura, Archeologia, Restauro volume monografico di "Ricerche di Storia dell'Arte" nn. 103-104, Carocci, Roma 2011.